Why impulses = choosing

Lately, I’ve been thinking a lot about free will.

Free will is a tricky thing. I made up my mind that it’s a thing that exists in the world I exist in a while ago, so that’s all dealt with…
But there are still some issues to sort out. Things like the subconscious, and whether decisions are ever made in that dark corner of your mind, or what this will I’m talking about as a thing in itself, floating around somewhere outside of the deterministic universe (Because that is how I talk about  it) really is.

In the context of free will, I also think about impulses. I think about how making a choice might mean choosing between impulses rather than coming up with a suitable choice for an action yourself and then going through with it. Or how following a sudden impulse seems so far away from that very active way of choosing your way that made me believe in free will in the first place.

Earlier today (tonight) I walked home and it was dark. I stopped right outside the house I live in and looked to the left of that house. I was looking at the part of the woods behind the house that kind of sticks out at both sides of it.
I was looking at the shadows and feeling afraid, as I usually do when I’m alone, looking at shadows. I was also thinking about how I sometimes breathe faster when it’s dark outside, and how that reminds me of panic attacks (which is a small or bigger than small problem in the lives of some people I know). I thought “I shouldn’t encourage this. I shouldn’t let my body react like this to darkness, because one day I might end up having panic attacks too.” And I decided to go where I would be even more scared. The dark spot with trees, sticking out from behind my home.

This would definitely fall into the “impulse” category of actions.
It took me about half a minute to come up with the idea, decide to do it, and start doing it. It took me less than two minutes to finish it (Unless you count the time that passed while I just stood there, listening to creepy sounds coming from the woods).
But this small rebellion against my fear of the dark was just one part of a bigger plan to try not to let fear get in the way of other, more important things. I’ve made up my mind several times before to ignore fear when I can, if it’s keeping me from life.

So. If it’s a part of a carefully formed plan, created over time and as a result of much thinking on the subject… Is it really that impulsive?
And even if it is, can anyone claim I didn’t make the decision myself? I doubt my subconscious, animal self, was telling me to move closer to the dark. In fact, I could feel my deepest self yelling at the higher levels of my mind to stop and turn around. Obviously, this was the active, aware-of-exactly-what-I’m-doing me, choosing to “face” my fears – or whatever it was I was doing.

To make some sort of point here… Impulses may seem like  involuntary thoughts, and it makes sense that it’s whether or not to act on them that’s the actual choice. But sometimes impulses aren’t random ideas, throwing themselves at your mind when you least expect it.
Sometimes they’re the love-child of every decision you’ve ever made in your entire life, and they just want to help you do what you already chose to do.



Filed under Uncategorized

9 responses to “Why impulses = choosing

  1. This is the only way I have always reacted in my life. Sometimes, I feel our ‘animal instinct’ is the best thing in us! Because it is this ‘impulse’ that drives us up the supposedly invincible wall and emerge victorious. For me, every action – be it stupid, intelligent, dreamy, impractical – germinates from the seed of my crazy ‘impulse’. I like your writing…stumbled upon it through one of your comments on a poet’s blog 🙂

    • Hmm… I suppose I’m in the choose between your impulses-camp. Instincts are mean to be used – and ignored. Or used, but not followed.
      But the point of this post is to try to show that impulses don’t have to be part of your animal instinct, but can be a result of your thoughts and earlier – chosen – actions. Impulse as a sophisticated tool, almost. Or something like it. Anyway, I’m glad you liked it. ^^

  2. It kind of reminds me of a type of behaviorism that states something along the lines that every decision you’ve made up to a certain point in your life along with the emotions and feelings you are having in that very moment dictates what your decision will be…even if it feels random (or impulsive). I am agreeing in a way, and in another way I was just thinking how the most random of actions are really the sum of all or our former selves.

    • Interesting… Though I don’t think anything “dictates” your decisions – except for yourself. I’m a hardcore believer in free will as a truly free one.
      And even more than I believe it, I want it to be true. I suppose that’s why I try to figure out ways for impulses to be a part of your free will. ^^

  3. I found you through the comment you left on my work, Protostellar Phase. You have a great sense of humor and an engaging writing style. I especially enjoyed your piece about your fan encounter – can’t wait to read more.

  4. Linking actions and decisions over time creates a network. The network, built by your will, supports and grows itself by poking you with impulses. I like that.


Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s